7 Weird Gifts To Give To Your Girlfriend, So Think Twice Before Buying These

I wasn’t exactly dating the guy anymore, but he was significant. He’d recently moved back to Chicago and I was hurt by how he’d left things between us. And he knew it. One day I came home to a generic brown box from Amazon. Inside were three jars of pickled peppers. I don’t particularly like pickled peppers, had never heard of the brand before, and had no idea why I’d received them–the best I could figure, they were a belated birthday gift from my foodie aunt and uncle. I scrounged around for the receipt, and listed in the comments it said, ‘I was going to send you flowers, but you can’t eat flowers, and these will last longer.’ Turns out the pickles were a Chicago specialty. Fair enough, dude. Fair enough.

— Allie*, 24

In college, this younger boy who had a crush on me who I made out with once brought me a tiny pumpkin on Halloween as a gift. He had drawn a creepy face on it.

— Iman, 23

For my birthday one year, the mom of a guy I was dating at the time gifted me a vibrating pillow. It wasn’t marketed as sex toy as far as I know/could tell, it was just a blue, round-shaped fluffy pillow that vibrated. I literally don’t have any helpful context to explain why this was a gift she gave me, but um, it was nice? I appreciated it?

— Annie, 25

My boyfriend gave me a stuffed llama with the word ‘crouton’ printed on it simply because I think llamas are cute and think Crouton would be a funny name for a dog. It’s the most random thing I own.

— Hannah, 25

My boyfriend once gave me an electric toothbrush. We’d never had a conversation about toothbrushes, dental hygiene, or teeth in general, yet he gave me an electric toothbrush. Also, it wasn’t for any particular occasion, just a random gift. When I asked him why he gave this to me, he said he thought I’d always been jealous of his! Weird, but honestly a really useful gift!

— Kelly, 24.

I had a pair of Ryan Gosling socks that I couldn’t find, so I put them on my Christmas list. My boyfriend couldn’t find them online, but what he could find was a Ryan Gosling pillow case and t-shirt. I ended up finding the socks, so now I look like I have the creepiest obsession with him!

— Morgan, 25

My ex-boyfriend gave me lingerie for a Valentine’s Day that we were together, and I thought it was the weirdest thing. It made me feel like I had to wear it all the time, which may not have been the case, but he kept asking me why I didn’t wear it more often. It just made me feel super uncomfortable because I see lingerie as something I should get myself and wear when I want to, not when a man tells me to because he bought it for me.

— Christy, 23

If you receive a gift from a SO that’s just plain weird, take heart. Even if the gift itself isn’t that great, you’ll get a lot of mileage out of telling the story of the gift at dinner parties forever. And that’s a pretty valuable gift, if you ask me.

*Name has been changed.